pick your 17

[playfuldodger]

ok, we can all go round slaggin others players and coaching staff off for there mistakes, but who would you play and where from the current or reserve teams, i have my own opinions, but i am no coach, there are players here that want to wear the wigan jersey and show wot wigan is about and there are players that like a wage for walking or running round half hearted, so if u where coach wot team would u have??????????

[100% Warrior]

If selecting from a fully fit squad my 17 would be:

1. Richards
2. Roberts
3. Goulding
4. Carmont
5. Ainscough
6. S Tomkins
7. Leuluai
8. Fielden
9. McIlorum
10. O'Carroll
11. Hansen
12. O'Loughlin
13. J Tomkins

14. Riddell
15. Hock
16. Feka
17. Prescott

[THE 18th Man]

If selecting from a fully fit squad my 17 would be:

1. Richards
2. Roberts
3. Goulding
4. Carmont
5. Ainscough
6. S Tomkins
7. Leuluai
8. Fielden
9. McIlorum
10. O'Carroll
11. Hansen
12. O'Loughlin
13. J Tomkins

14. Riddell
15. Hock
16. Feka
17. Prescott

that is my exact squad but if presscot is injured then bring in Ben Davies

[ajsefc]

1.Richards
2.Roberts
3.Goulding
4.Carmont
5.Ainscough or Pryce - need to see more of both them
6.Sam Tomkins
7.Tim Smith
8.Stuart Fielden
9.Thomas Leuluai
10.Paul Precott
11.Gaz Hock
12.Harrison Hansen
13.Lockers
14.O Carroll
15.Feka
16.Joel Tomkins
17.Ridell

[GeoffN]

1.Richards
2.Roberts
3.Goulding
4.Carmont
5.Ainscough or Pryce - need to see more of both them
6.Sam Tomkins
7.Tim Smith
8.Stuart Fielden
9.Thomas Leuluai
10.Paul Precott
11.Gaz Hock
12.Harrison Hansen
13.Lockers
14.O Carroll
15.Feka
16.Joel Tomkins
17.Ridell

I don't think I'd have Riddell ahead of McIlorum, although to be fair we haven't seen him fit yet.

Mine would be pretty much the same as 100% warrior, although I would like to see Pryce in there somewhere (just not sure where, or who to drop).

[lucky 13]

I don't think I'd have Riddell ahead of McIlorum, although to be fair we haven't seen him fit yet.

Mine would be pretty much the same as 100% warrior, although I would like to see Pryce in there somewhere (just not sure where, or who to drop).

Spot on I would play Pryce ,Baily if any injuries also get other young lads in Farrell, Mossop ect .

[cherrywarrior]

Coach : Edwards!

1. Richards
2. Roberts
3. Goulding
4. Carmont
5. Ainscough
6. Sam Tompkins
7. Tim Smith
8. Fielden
9. Tommy Leuluai
10. Feka
11. Hock
12. Locky
13. Joel Tompkins

14. Prescot
15. Eamon O Carroll
16. Hansen
17. Bailey


Not in squad, Riddell, Coley, Mathers, Phelps (sorry Cameron) Pryce (sorry again - but i dont think he is match fit yet) Mc Illorum (not good enough - yet - also i dont think i saw him throw a ball backwards all night on friday, and he gives away too many penalties with is dodgey tackling style)... Nobby - anyone else think its as if he doesnt know what to do with the squad come match day, i.e. playing Feka for under ten mins in the first half, then playing him for 25 mins in the second???

[mackie1981]

my 17
1. Roberts
2. Ainscough
3. Goulding
4. Carmont
5. Richards
6. S.Tomkins
7. Smith
8. Fielden
9. Leuluai
10. O'Carroll
11. Hock
12. O'loughlin
13. J. Tomkins

14. Feka
15. Hansen
16. McIllorum
17. Prescott

Dont think i can say much else but Bailey is ok but takes up a quota spot and is no better than the other second rowers we have. Same sort of thing for Phelps but he is a back. Would like to have Pryce and Riddell in but not seen either at their best yet as both are no where near fit. [/quote]

[old hooker]

I would pick,

1 Richards
2 Roberts
3 Pryce
4 Carmont
5 Ainscough
6 S Tompkins
7 Leuluai
8 Prescott
9 Riddell
10 Hock
11 Bailey
12 OLoughlin
13 J Tompkins

14 Feka
15 Hansen
16 Mcilorum
17 O Carroll

Mathers,Phelps,Smith,Fielden and Coley out on loan(if anyone would have them so we could generate some cash for 2 props and a top class no 6 to teach Sam Tompkins the ropes as i believe he could be our stand off for years to come.

[tommo46]

1.Richards
2.roberts
3.hock
4.carmont
5.ainscough
6.s.tomkins
7.Leuluai
8.fielden
9.riddell
10.feka
11.hansen
12.bailey/lockers not sure
13.tomkins

14.mcilorum
15.phelps
16.pryce
17.prescott/o'carroll maybe both instesd of pryce/phelps

this is harder than i first thought :conf: