Riddell v. McIlorum

[Webby1971]

There can be no argument, I'm not 100% sure because the game has only just finished but we must have conceeded 22 out of the 28 points whilst Riddell was on and scored 30 of our 36 points whilst he was off, I rest my case. We obviously scored ALL our points whist Sam was on and ZERO whilst Smith was on. When will it sink in with Nobby??????????????????? Great win lads in the face of such adversity and some shocking decisions.

[Wigan_forever1985]

Smith was took off v.early when Hull were in the box seat while i agree with your overall argument i dont think the stats on him ring as true as that. However the Riddell vs Macca is bang on!

[turf]

McIlorum every time.

[THE 18th Man]

Mike by a mile

[Susi]

macca well better than ridell, also sam better than smith, sadly these commited passionate lads only get a match when our coach has no other choice, bout time he realised.

[cumbria_warrior]

Dont think there is anything to compare, riddell overweight along for the cash, had his day, Mike McIllorum, keen as mustard, young lad gives his all and always fired up. I know whom I would be playing

[white elephant]

mike is beter than piggy at the moment, sam T far better than smith !!!

[cumbria_warrior]

white elephant totally correct

[Mike]

I was saying with 20 mins to go that it was not all over as we would have to do 20 mins with Riddell on the park. Nobby subs by the clock, no matter how well macca is doing he will be brought off. At one point in the second half we had 4 tackles in a set of 6 before Riddell got to the play the ball. This after being on the field for 10 minutes.

We're stuck with Riddell, unless we get a new coach who can offload him on a free transfer somewhere in the UK or Aus.

If this can be done, our other options are to bring in a new hooker, or stick tommy in as a hooker and bring in a hlaf back. In terms of needing an organiser - after today it looks like we've already got one in SamT.

[cumbria_warrior]

My local amateur team may have a place in there A team for riddell, they play in barrow and district league, Fancy it mark?