Re: who would make a great coach

ajsefc · Post by **ajsefc** » Sun Feb 15, 2009 7:01 pm

I'd love Edwards or Lam from an emotional point of view but if I was to choose someone away from the clubs history it would be Fran Cummins.

He has bee assistant for 2 grand final winning teams for the last 2 years with 2 different manager. I know for a fact he comes up with the game plans for every game although Mclellan picks the team. He also wants to be his own man and is a big believer in bringing youth through

Paleaaesina_Da_Beast · Sun Feb 15, 2009 9:36 pm

LAMMMY!

OAMJSONA · Post by **OAMJSONA** » Sun Feb 15, 2009 9:50 pm

Shaun will coach us one day but not yet he will only come back once his lad as finished

Ellery would be a good interim but do not know if he would come back

Kearney or lammy would be a good combination

but the one constant thing is Noble as got to go

the-Bowtun-Warrior · Post by **the-Bowtun-Warrior** » Sun Feb 15, 2009 9:57 pm

ellery is off the 'talent show'. . . He can take over in the morning

Please god!

THE 18th Man · Post by **THE 18th Man** » Sun Feb 15, 2009 10:29 pm

when we had no coaches in 2005 and everybody was chanting who they wanted and i was chanting Adrian Lams Barmie Army

medlocke · Post by **medlocke** » Sun Feb 15, 2009 11:48 pm

Frano Botica and Bobby Goulding

old hooker · Post by **old hooker** » Mon Feb 16, 2009 10:51 pm

Edwards and Hanley, two of my favourite players of all time,but for coach at Wigan definitely not. Both are far too abrasive with very big egos.At the slightest hint of a disagreement they would quite probably just walk out unless they got their own way,after all neither of them need the money.Frankly i dont think there is a coach in SL good enough so even though it goes against the grain i would pick someone who ia available in the NRL,Adrian Lam would certainly be on my list

DaveO · Post by **DaveO** » Tue Feb 17, 2009 12:16 pm

old hooker wrote:Edwards and Hanley, two of my favourite players of all time,but for coach at Wigan definitely not. Both are far too abrasive with very big egos.At the slightest hint of a disagreement they would quite probably just walk out unless they got their own way,after all neither of them need the money.Frankly i dont think there is a coach in SL good enough so even though it goes against the grain i would pick someone who ia available in the NRL,Adrian Lam would certainly be on my list

Tend to agree about Hanley. He has after all done it before (walk away that is).

On the other hand Edwards has shown no sign of not being able to handle the politics of being a coach. When he was a player and younger he may have been liable to let his ego get in the way but I think he is much more mature now.

That doesn't mean he would be daft enough to stay on here were he coach if he felt IL was not doing the right thing. There is a difference there though compared to letting his ego rule his head.

Dave

jackoh · Post by **jackoh** » Tue Feb 17, 2009 12:25 pm

I`ld love to see Edwards here but can`t see him coming.
Hanley had problems with the Stains re his management style , so he could be a problem .
Adrian Lam would be my preferred choice with Andy Farrell as assistant .
noble would be put in charge of the Academy team , so he can see how good they are !, But on second thoughts they are a flambouyant rugby team which noble might ruin