Charnley

[DaveO]

Back in the rumour mill where it belongs.

[ddtftf]

UNION

[TrueBlueWarrior]

I am a massive Charnley fan but to say we will miss him more than Sam is ridiculous.

That's probably why no-one has said it!

Check what Meds said Kitt, I assumed he meant on a playing basis as any other basis is irrelevant!!

[TrueBlueWarrior]

Also check what jondebaptist20 said Kitt!!

[Kittwazzer]

Must confess I'd missed jondebaptist20 but I read Med's comment to say he personally would be more gutted. I inferred that it was because he'd already come to terms with Sam's departure!

[medlocke]

Sam was always going to leave so why cry over spilt milk, Charnley however is a different kettle of fish, like Farrell i can see Charnley being a big part of the club for many years so would be worse in the long run for the club if he left imo

[markill]

If there was much to this then you'd think we'd have done more about trying to get Briscoe

[yokozuna]

Would be gutted to see Charnley go. He seems like one of those who'd be at Wigan for a long time, and is purpose-built for rugby league.

Don't know about the validity of any of the rumours - but I would still be surprised to see him move any time soon - especially to union.

[Owd Codger]

What pleasure some supporters get in starting these rumours is beyond me.

Unless of course, they are started from those at the dark side of Billinge Hill.

[East Stand Faithful]

Anyone would think that the conveyor belt had broken down!

I know you always err on the side of optimism but can I ask you this:

At what point would you start to worry about the amount of players Wigan were losing to NRL/ Union?

Do your believe it doesn't matter and that no matter how many players we lose we can replace them with local talent or is there a point at which you would become concerned?